Social Security Talking Points
For your use only – Do NOT leave with the Member of Congress

Social Security and Social Work

• Social Security provides economic security to some 44 million Americans who are retired, disabled or the survivor of a deceased parent. It provides a permanent, inflation-protected benefit that provides a higher replacement rate for those who had lower earnings.
• Social security is predicated on the notion that there is an intergenerational, shared responsibility for basic income security of all older people. Just as we are responsible for our children's economic security, so are we responsible for the economic security of our seniors. Social security allows us to meet this responsibility in a just way.
• Social security privatization places undue investment risk on seniors living on a fixed income. Individuals already can choose to place their own money in private retirement accounts. Sometimes these accounts earn money; other times they lose money. In social security, investment risk is borne by the federal government, not individuals. Seniors need the economic security provided by current social security, not economic insecurity that would be certain to follow in private plans.

Talking Points from moveon.org

• Social Security provides monthly benefits to some 44 million Americans who are retired, disabled or the survivor of a deceased parent. It provides most of the income for older Americans — some 64 percent of their support. It has lifted generations of seniors out of poverty.
• Social Security is not in crisis. That is an outright lie perpetrated in order to create the urgency for radical changes. Under conservative forecasts, the long-term challenges in Social Security do not manifest themselves until 2042. Even then Social Security has 70 percent of needed funds. That shortfall is smaller than the amount needed in 1983, the last time we overhauled Social Security. George Bush's Social Security crisis-talk is an effort to create a specter of doom — just like the weapons of mass destruction claim in Iraq .
• Phasing out Social Security and replacing it with privatized accounts means one thing: massive cuts in monthly benefits for everybody. Social Security privatization requires diverting taxes used to pay current benefits into privatized accounts invested in risky stocks. Without that money, Social Security benefits will inevitably be cut — some proposals even cut benefits of current retirees. These benefit cuts are inevitable, since diverting Social Security money into privatized accounts means less money to pay current and future benefits.
• Every serious privatization proposal raises the Social Security retirement age to 70. That might be fine if you're a Washington special interest lobbyist but it is incredibly unfair to blue-collar Americans with tough, physical jobs, or for African Americans and Latinos with lower life expectancies.
• Privatization means gambling with your retirement security. There is probably an appropriate place for a little stock market risk in retirement planning — but it isn't Social Security. Privatization exposes your entire retirement portfolio to stock market risks — and the risk that you'll outlive any of your savings at retirement. You can't outlive your Social Security benefit.
• So who does benefit? Wall Street. Giant financial services firms have been salivating for decades over the prospect of taking over Social Security. Wall Street would make billions of dollars in profit by managing the privatized accounts — money that would come directly from your benefits.